Skip to main content

CSN Bay Area

HOME  >  NEWS  >  SPORTS
Judge rejects San Jose antitrust claims against MLB
Share This Post
Comments
Friday, October 11, 2013 - 12:45pm
Follow @csnbaggs

UPDATE: (2 p.m. on Friday) -- MLB released the following statement on Friday afternoon:

“Major League Baseball is pleased that the Court dismissed the heart of San Jose's action and confirmed that MLB has the legal right to make decisions about the relocation of its member Clubs. The Court dismissed all of San Jose's state and federal law claims challenging that right. We are confident that the remaining state law claims, which assert that San Jose's costs associated with the option agreement for the sale of real estate were increased by the timing of MLB's decision-making process, will be decided in MLB's favor, and that San Jose has not suffered any compensable injury."

***

The city of San Jose lost its antitrust argument against Major League Baseball Friday morning, but might have preserved an avenue to pursue litigation against the league for blocking efforts to relocate the Oakland A’s to the South Bay.
 
Federal judge Ronald M. Whyte upheld MLB’s right to regulate the relocation of teams under the “business of baseball” clause that exempts the league from federal antitrust laws. But Whyte also wrote in his opinion that MLB willfully interfered with an option between San Jose and A’s owner Lew Wolff to purchase land for a future stadium site near the Diridon rail station, and labeled the league's 91-year-old exemption as "unrealistic, inconsistent or illogical."
 
“Although MLB's frustration of the option agreement is not an antitrust violation, MLB is nonetheless ... engaged in acts ... indicating an intent to frustrate the contract," Whyte wrote.
 
San Jose attorney Philip Gregory told the San Jose Mercury News that the opinion upholds the city’s tort claims against MLB and provides a way for the case to go forward.
 
“The A's may have lost last night, but the A's and the city of San Jose won today," Gregory told the newspaper.
 
The Detroit Tigers eliminated the A’s in Game 5 of the AL Division Series Thursday night.

[RELATED: Tigers-A's LDS recap]

The A’s have attempted to move to San Jose for several years, but they ceded territorial rights to Santa Clara County to the Giants in the early 1990s as a courtesy when the Giants were exploring relocation options from Candlestick Park. The Giants have consistently moved to block any intrusion into Santa Clara County, citing the effect it would have on their franchise value and sponsorship agreements.

It would take three-fourths approval of MLB owners to overturn the Giants' territorial claim.

 

NBCBayArea.com

There is no data to display.

Video

Bumgarner reflects on poor start against Cardinals in 2012 NLCS
Raiders Quick Hits: More Wildcat with Sparano at helm
Sandoval: 'We're going to do it again like 2012'
Romo: Wainwright 'knows how to show up on a daily basis '

Giants

Replacing NLCS MVP, Giants have full faith in Panik
Bochy: Morse likely on NLCS roster
Cardinals add Pierzynski to NLCS roster
Giants, Cardinals remind us once again that it's October
Read More

Athletics

ALCS Game 1: Royals hit two homers in 10th, beat O's 8-6
A's waive Dunn, claim RHP De Leon
A tougher AL West will greet A's in 2015
A's 1B Moss, C Vogt scheduled for surgery
Read More

Sharks

Sharks notes: Hand injury delays Goodrow's arrival
Sharks' Couture disappointed he's not an alternate captain
Ex-Shark Boyle hurt in Rangers debut
Sharks rookie Mueller encouraging in NHL debut
Read More

49ers

Fangio transcript: 49ers D prepared for size, speed receivers
Roman transcript: 'Field goals are evil?'
NFL penalties up more than two per game in 2014
49ers injury report: Brock, Davis unlikely for Monday's game
Read More

Raiders

Could Sparano prompt Wildcat revival in Oakland?
Raiders injury report: Watson set for 'important' start
Chargers-Raiders matchup No. 2: Branden Oliver vs. Miles Burris
Olson: Tweaks, but no 'wholesale changes' to Raiders offense
Read More

Warriors

Monte Poole's Warriors chat transcript (10.10.14)
Rewind: Good vibes after Warriors' domination of Lakers
Warriors' Iguodala suffers broken nose against Lakers
Instant Replay: W's handle Lakers 120-105 in preseason play
Read More

NCAA

Fresno State falls to UNLV on FG in OT
No. 25 Stanford quiets Halliday, beats WSU 34-17
Stanford looks to bounce back against Washington State
Top NFL prospect Gurley suspended by Georgia indefinitely
Read More
  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • MLB Standings
  • Insider Andrew Baggarly
  • Amy G
  • Buy Giants Gear
  • Buy Giants Tickets

Latest News

Replacing NLCS MVP, Giants have full faith in Panik
(7)
Andrew Baggarly

More Stories

Bochy: Morse likely on NLCS roster
(2)
Cardinals add Pierzynski to NLCS roster
(8)
See more >

More Stories

Giants, Cardinals remind us once again that it's October
Adam Wainwright, Mike Matheny -- NOW
See more >

GIANTS VIDEO

Bumgarner reflects on poor start against Cardinals in 2012 NLCS
Bumgarner reflects on poor start against Cardinals in 2012 NLCS
See more >

GIANTS INSIDER

  • Replacing NLCS MVP, Giants have full faith in Panik
  • Bochy: Morse likely on NLCS roster
  • Giants notes: Morse planned for NLCS roster, faith in Strickland
  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • MLB Standings
  • Insider Joe Stiglich
  • Buy Athletics Gear
  • Buy Athletics Tickets

Latest News

ALCS Game 1: Royals hit two homers in 10th, beat O's 8-6
(1)
Associated Press

More Stories

A's waive Dunn, claim RHP De Leon
(1)
A tougher AL West will greet A's in 2015
(1)
See more >

More Stories

A's 1B Moss, C Vogt scheduled for surgery
Report: A's grant Twins permission to interview Hale
(1)
See more >

A's VIDEO

Melvin: 'When you lose a game of that magnitude it's an empty feeling'
Melvin: 'When you lose a game of that magnitude it's an empty feeling'
See more >

A's INSIDER

  • A tougher AL West will greet A's in 2015
  • A's 1B Moss, C Vogt scheduled for surgery
  • Hudson finally gets to experience postseason joy
  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • NHL Standings
  • Insider Kevin Kurz
  • Buy Sharks Gear
  • Buy Sharks Tickets

Latest News

Sharks notes: Hand injury delays Goodrow's arrival
Kevin Kurz

More Stories

Sharks' Couture disappointed he's not an alternate captain
(12)
Ex-Shark Boyle hurt in Rangers debut
(2)
See more >

More Stories

Sharks rookie Mueller encouraging in NHL debut
(3)
Kevin Kurz's Sharks chat transcript (10.10.14)
See more >

SHARKS VIDEO

Brodie and Kevin: Sharks show positive signs in opener vs. Kings
Brodie and Kevin: Sharks show positive signs in opener vs. Kings
See more >

SHARKS INSIDER

  • Cardinals leaning on surgically-repaired Carpenter in Game 2
  • Instant Replay: Giants' comeback falls short in Game 1 loss
  • Kelly to miss first two NLCS games, at least
  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • NBA Standings
  • Insider Monte Poole
  • Buy Warriors Gear
  • Buy Warriors Tickets

Latest News

Monte Poole's Warriors chat transcript (10.10.14)
Monte Poole

More Stories

Rewind: Good vibes after Warriors' domination of Lakers
(42)
Warriors' Iguodala suffers broken nose against Lakers
(13)
See more >

more stories

Instant Replay: W's handle Lakers 120-105 in preseason play
(2)
Fast Forward: Warriors set to face 'Superman' Kobe, Lakers
(8)
See more >

WARRIORS VIDEO

Curry excited to see how Warriors stack up
Curry excited to see how Warriors stack up
See more >

WARRIORS INSIDER

  • Monte Poole's Warriors chat transcript (10.10.14)
  • Rewind: Good vibes after Warriors' domination of Lakers
  • Warriors' Iguodala suffers broken nose against Lakers
  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • NBA Standings
  • Insider Bill Herenda
  • Buy Kings Gear
  • Buy Kings Tickets
  • Channel locations

Latest News

Kings Outlook: Evans playing role in Cousins' development
Bill Herenda

More Stories

Fast Forward: Progress in China key for Kings
Kings Outlook: Thompson after longevity, increased role
(1)
See more >

More Stories

Cousins busts Kings rookie Stauskas admiring per diem
(3)
Kings Outlook: Will McLemore realize his full potential?
See more >

Kings Video

Stauskas details what he needs to work on most
Stauskas details what he needs to work on most
See more >

There is no data to display.

  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • NFL Standings
  • Insider Matt Maiocco
  • Buy 49ers Gear
  • Buy 49ers Tickets

Latest News

Fangio transcript: 49ers D prepared for size, speed receivers
(2)
CSN Bay Area staff

More Stories

Roman transcript: 'Field goals are evil?'
(5)
NFL penalties up more than two per game in 2014
(4)
See more >

More stories

49ers injury report: Brock, Davis unlikely for Monday's game
(4)
SJPD officers now barred from 49ers-related assignments
(12)
See more >

49ers VIDEO

49ers Quick Hits: Justifying Gore's decreased workload
49ers Quick Hits: Justifying Gore's decreased workload
See more >

49ers INSIDER

  • 49ers injury report: Brock, Davis unlikely for Monday's game
  • 49ers re-sign Osgood, release QB Josh Johnson
  • Gore's limited rushing attempts part of plan
  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • NFL Standings
  • Insider Scott Bair
  • Buy Raiders Gear
  • Buy Raiders Tickets

Latest News

Could Sparano prompt Wildcat revival in Oakland?
(3)
Scott Bair

More Stories

Raiders injury report: Watson set for 'important' start
Chargers-Raiders matchup No. 2: Branden Oliver vs. Miles Burris
(2)
See more >

More Stories

Olson: Tweaks, but no 'wholesale changes' to Raiders offense
(15)
NFL capsule: Raiders seven-point underdogs vs. Chargers
(2)
See more >

RAIDERS VIDEO

Raiders Quick Hits: More Wildcat with Sparano at helm
Raiders Quick Hits: More Wildcat with Sparano at helm
See more >

RAIDERS INSIDER

  • Could Sparano prompt Wildcat revival in Oakland?
  • Raiders injury report: Watson set for 'important' start
  • Chargers-Raiders matchup No. 2: Branden Oliver vs. Miles Burris
  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • MLS Standings
  • MLS Player Leaders
  • Buy Quakes Gear
  • Buy Quakes Tickets

Top Story

US, Ecuador tie 1-1 in Donovan's final friendly
(1)
Associated Press

More Stories

Klinsmann: Donovan 'could have done a bit more'
Portland Timbers blank Earthquakes 3-0
See more >

Quakes Video

Wondolowski reflects on his World Cup experience
Wondolowski reflects on his World Cup experience
See more >

Shop

ANDREW BAGGARLY

Replacing NLCS MVP, Giants have full faith in Panik
(7)
See more >

JOE STIGLICH

A tougher AL West will greet A's in 2015
(1)
See more >

MATT MAIOCCO

49ers injury report: Brock, Davis unlikely for Monday's game
(4)
See more >

SCOTT BAIR

Could Sparano prompt Wildcat revival in Oakland?
(3)
See more >

MONTE POOLE

Monte Poole's Warriors chat transcript (10.10.14)
See more >

BILL HERENDA

Kings Outlook: Evans playing role in Cousins' development
See more >

KEVIN KURZ

Sharks notes: Hand injury delays Goodrow's arrival
See more >

RAY RATTO

Don't even attempt to predict Giants-Cardinals NLCS

FIND OUT HOW TO WIN 49ERS TICKETS!

49ers

Click here to find out how to win 49ers tickets!

ENTER TO WIN SHARKS TICKETS!

Sharks Tix
Click here for the chance to win Sharks tickets!

FOLLOW US!

Follow us on Twitter @CSNAuthentic.

NCAA

Top NFL prospect Gurley suspended by Georgia indefinitely
Ray Ratto's Top 25 college football rankings: Week 7

MORE

  • SaberCats
  • Fight Sports
  • Motor Sports
  • GolfChannel.com
  • Tennis
  • Ray Ratto

 

TICKETS

  • Giants Tickets
  • A's Tickets
  • 49ers Tickets
  • Raiders Tickets
  • Warriors Tickets
  • Kings Tickets
  • Sharks Tickets
Curry Jersey
Giants Fitted Hat
49ers Hoodie

Mega Menu: Shop

  • Giants
  • A's Shop
  • 49ers
  • Raiders Shop
  • Warriors
  • Kings Shop
  • Sharks Shop

Mega Menu: Shop - Tickets

  • Giants Tickets
  • A's Tickets
  • 49ers Tickets
  • Raiders Tickets
  • Warriors Tickets
  • Kings Tickets
  • Sharks Tickets

Latest Videos

Bumgarner reflects on poor start against Cardinals in 2012 NLCS
Bumgarner reflects on poor start against Cardinals in 2012 NLCS
See more >

ONLINE SHOWS

  • Carpool Confessions
  • Amy G’s Exclusives
  • Buster Knows Squat
  • Humm BB
  • Bullshootin'

TV SHOWS

  • All Videos
  • SportsNet Central
  • Yahoo SportsTalk Live

INSIDERS

  • Ray Ratto - Senior Insider
  • Matt Maiocco - 49ers
  • Scott Bair - Raiders
  • Monte Poole - Warriors
  • Bill Herenda - Kings
  • Kevin Kurz - Sharks
  • Andrew Baggarly - Giants
  • Joe Stiglich - A's
  • TV Schedule - Bay Area and California
  • Channel Locations - Bay Area
  • Channel Locations - California