Skip to main content

CSN Bay Area

HOME  >  NEWS  >  SPORTS
Judge's decision means NFL may have to pay more
Share This Post
Comments
Wednesday, January 15, 2014 - 3:45pm

NEW YORK — The NFL may be on the hook for more money than it expected if a federal judge can't be convinced that its $765 million concussion settlement with more than 4,500 former players will be adequate to pay out benefits over the 65-year life of the agreement.

The deal hit a snag Tuesday when a federal judge asked both parties to back up their assertions that the agreement negotiated over several months is appropriate.

U.S. District Judge Anita B. Brody denied a motion that was meant to serve as a preliminary approval for the settlement, seeking more information from the parties.

She wrote that she was "primarily concerned that not all retired NFL football players who ultimately receive a qualifying diagnosis or their (families) ... will be paid," and that the lawyers for both parties have not addressed those concerns.

Given the judge's ruling, the two sides will need to offer more evidence the fund will be sufficient or possibly have the NFL add money to the pot. Otherwise, they may be left to start over.

"We are confident that the settlement is fair and adequate, and look forward to demonstrating that to the court," NFL spokesman Greg Aiello said.

[RELATED: Judge: $765M might not cover NFL concussion claims]

Meanwhile, former players looking to receive assistance for the injuries they sustained while playing in the league will have to wait to be compensated.

The two sides agreed in late August, just before the season kicked off and the issue largely went to the back burner, awaiting Brody's decision. The weekly accounting of brain injuries on the field, despite efforts to reduce them, continued to make headlines.

Brody pointed out that the class of approximately 20,000 could overwhelm the fund, even if only 10 percent of its members file claims against the $675 million set aside to pay claims, working out to $337,500 per player.

The maximum payments in the settlement include $5 million for a younger retiree with Lou Gehrig's disease, $3 million for serious dementia, and $25,000 for an 80-year-old with early dementia.

Sol Weiss, a lead lawyer for the ex-players, remained confident the class-action settlement will ultimately be approved.

"I am very confident that the (actuarial) people we used are right, and that there will be enough money to cover these claims for 65 years," Weiss said.

The remainder of the $765 settlement is being earmarked for neurological testing and education. Lawyers will be paid on top of that by the NFL, meaning the suit would cost the league $900 million — or about 10 percent of one year's annual revenues.

Brody also took issue with another part of the original agreement, writing in a footnote that she was concerned that the agreement prevents participants from suing the NCAA and other amateur football organizations.

"I'm not sure why the NFL would insist on that," said Gabe Feldman, a law professor who directs the sports law program at the Tulane University Law School.

More than 4,500 former players filed the suit, some accusing the league of fraud for its handling of concussions. They include former Dallas Cowboys running back Tony Dorsett and Super Bowl-winning quarterback Jim McMahon, who suffers from dementia.

Brody's hand-picked mediator, former federal judge Layn R. Phillips, led several months of negotiations last year and has called the deal fair to both sides.

If and when the parties can satisfy all of Brody's concerns, she would then give preliminary approval to the settlement. Following that would be a hearing at which people with objections can speak and have their issues addressed before final settlement and payments.

NBCBayArea.com

There is no data to display.

Video

McLellan on Pavelski: 'He's got it going right now'
Highlights: Dueling hat tricks in Tampa Bay
Pavelski reacts to first NHL hat trick after win
Sochi 2014: Vlasic ready for responsibility of being an Olympian

Giants

Giants agree to terms with three players; no deal for Belt yet
Guillermo Mota finds a new home this spring
20 questions (and answers) on MLB's expanded replay rules
Charlie Manuel returning to Phillies
Read More

Athletics

A's Melvin: Expanded replay 'ultimately good for the game'
Nationals avoid arbitration with Blevins
A-Rod says suspension could be beneficial
Jay-Z's Roc Nation signs Vallejo's Sabathia
Read More

Sharks

Sharks, Lightning make history in wild game
Pavelski's hat trick cues win to cap Sharks' road trip
In hindsight, Boyle says he came back too soon
Instant Replay: Sharks recover miraculously in Tampa Bay
Read More

49ers

Maiocco vs. O'Neil: Who will win NFC title game?
49ers' trade for Boldin paying off, while Harvin remains sidelined
Vegas still giving 49ers third-best odds to win Super Bowl
Ex-NFL star Darren Sharper arrested for suspicion of rape
Read More

Raiders

AP source: Jets QB Smith leaves plane after argument
McKenzie: Allen's Raiders must improve in the clutch
Aaron Hernandez can't watch Patriots in AFC Championship
Police: Hernandez eyed as gunman in 2012 slayings
Read More

Warriors

Double-edged Warriors visit New Orleans
Failure of spectacular proportions for Warriors defense
Instant Replay: Durant's 54 too much for Warriors
Clippers sign forward Hedo Turkoglu
Read More

NCAA

Report: Jahvid Best joining Cal’s coaching staff
San Jose State lose to Wyoming, fall to 0-6 in MWC
Cal remains perfect in Pac-12, routes Wash. St.
Santa Clara kept at bay in 69-66 loss to USD
Read More
  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • MLB Standings
  • Buy Giants Gear
  • Buy Giants Tickets
  • Amy G.
  • Insider Andrew Baggarly

Latest News

Giants agree to terms with three players; no deal for Belt yet
(29)
Andrew Baggarly

More Stories

Guillermo Mota finds a new home this spring
(4)
20 questions (and answers) on MLB's expanded replay rules
(4)
See more >

GIANTS VIDEO

YSTL: Hall of Fame panel debates latest vote
YSTL: Hall of Fame panel debates latest vote
See more >

GIANTS TALK

Charlie Manuel returning to Phillies
Barry Bonds loses his crown

GIANTS INSIDER

There is no data to display.

  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • MLB Standings
  • Buy Athletics Gear
  • Buy Athletics Tickets

Latest News

A's Melvin: Expanded replay 'ultimately good for the game'
(2)
Joe Stiglich

More Stories

Nationals avoid arbitration with Blevins
A-Rod says suspension could be beneficial
See more >

A's VIDEO

Korach named Sportscaster of the Year
Korach named Sportscaster of the Year
See more >

A's TALK

Jay-Z's Roc Nation signs Vallejo's Sabathia
A's avoid arbitration with four key players
  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • NHL Standings
  • Buy Sharks Gear
  • Buy Sharks Tickets
  • Insider Kevin Kurz

Latest News

Sharks, Lightning make history in wild game
CSN Bay Area staff

More Stories

Pavelski's hat trick cues win to cap Sharks' road trip
In hindsight, Boyle says he came back too soon
See more >

SHARKS VIDEO

McLellan on Pavelski: 'He's got it going right now'
McLellan on Pavelski: 'He's got it going right now'
See more >

Features

Instant Replay: Sharks recover miraculously in Tampa Bay
Couture skates for first time since surgery

SHARKS INSIDER

There is no data to display.

  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • NBA Standings
  • Buy Warriors Gear
  • Buy Warriors Tickets

Latest News

Double-edged Warriors visit New Orleans
(1)
Monte Poole

More Stories

Failure of spectacular proportions for Warriors defense
(32)
Instant Replay: Durant's 54 too much for Warriors
(25)
See more >

WARRIORS VIDEO

Highlights: Durant has career night against Warriors
Highlights: Durant has career night against Warriors
See more >

Features

Clippers sign forward Hedo Turkoglu
Lakers’ Young suspended for throwing punch at Dragic

WARRIORS INSIDER

There is no data to display.

  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • NBA Standings
  • Buy Kings Gear
  • Buy Kings Tickets

Latest News

Kings blow fourth-quarter lead in Memphis
(1)
Associated Press

More Stories

Gay, Thomas, Kings stave off 'Wolves in Minnesota
After tough loss, Kings look to regroup against T'Wolves
See more >

Watch

Gay: 'For the most part, it's all about winning'
Gay: 'For the most part, it's all about winning'
See more >

Features

Cousins' 31 and 13 not enough to take down Indiana
Cousins named Western Conference Player of Week

Fantasy Hoops

  • The Daily Dose: Dose: Durant's Triple-double
  • PRO BASKETBALL TALK
  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • NFL Standings
  • Buy 49ers Tickets
  • Buy 49ers Gear
  • Insider Matt Maiocco

Latest News

Maiocco vs. O'Neil: Who will win NFC title game?
(1)
Matt Maiocco

More Stories

Vegas still giving 49ers third-best odds to win Super Bowl
(8)
49ers' trade for Boldin paying off, while Harvin remains sidelined
(8)
See more >

49ers VIDEO

YSTL: What is Jim Harbaugh's legacy in three NFL seasons?
YSTL: What is Jim Harbaugh's legacy in three NFL seasons?
See more >

WEEKLY REWIND

Rewind: 49ers heat up, roll over Panthers 23-10
(3)
Matt Maiocco

49ers INSIDER

  • NFL Draft moved to May
  • 'Tuck Rule' eliminated from NFL rulebook
  • Raiders look to turn Taiwan Jones into a cornerback
  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • NFL Standings
  • Buy Raiders Tickets
  • Buy Raiders Gear
  • Insider Scott Bair

Latest News

AP source: Jets QB Smith leaves plane after argument
Associated Press

More Stories

McKenzie: Allen's Raiders must improve in the clutch
(9)
Aaron Hernandez can't watch Patriots in AFC Championship
(4)
See more >

RAIDERS VIDEO

Scott and Fallon: Raiders have money to make moves
Scott and Fallon: Raiders have money to make moves
See more >

WEEKLY REWIND

Raiders Rewind: Overmatched vs. Broncos
(29)
Scott Bair

RAIDERS INSIDER

  • McKenzie: Allen's Raiders must improve in the clutch
  • Raiders looking to retain some free agents, not all
  • McKenzie: 2013 Raiders 'a different 4-12'
  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • MLS Standings
  • MLS Player Leaders
  • Buy Quakes Gear
  • Buy Quakes Tickets

Top Story

Earthquakes sign French midfielder Jean-Baptiste Pierazzi
(1)
CSN Bay Area staff

More Stories

Wondolowski, Goodson join United States camp
(1)
Who got off easy in the World Cup draw?
See more >

Watch

Earthquakes beat FC Dallas 2-1, Corrales honored
Earthquakes beat FC Dallas 2-1, Corrales honored
See more >

Shop

ANDREW BAGGARLY

Giants agree to terms with three players; no deal for Belt yet
(29)
See more >

MONTE POOLE

Double-edged Warriors visit New Orleans
(1)
See more >

MATT MAIOCCO

Maiocco vs. O'Neil: Who will win NFC title game?
(1)
See more >

SCOTT BAIR

McKenzie: Allen's Raiders must improve in the clutch
(9)
See more >

KEVIN KURZ

Pavelski's hat trick cues win to cap Sharks' road trip
See more >

CASEY PRATT

RAY RATTO

Tattooed Seattle fan may get shipped to underprivileged country

TOP STORIES

  • AP source: Jets QB Smith leaves plane after argument
  • McKenzie: Allen's Raiders must improve in the clutch
  • Aaron Hernandez can't watch Patriots in AFC Championship

AFF

Enter here for the chance to win a pair of tickets to Authentic Fan Friday!

FOLLOW @CSNAUTHENTIC

@CSNAuthentic on Twitter

Facebook.com/CSNBayArea

CSN on Instagram

ALL-STAR TEACHER

Nominate your favorite All-Star Teacher today!

NCAA

Santa Clara kept at bay in 69-66 loss to USD
Bears throttle Huskies, remain perfect in Pac-12 play

MORE

  • SaberCats
  • Preps
  • Biz Ball
  • Fight Sports
  • Motor Sports
  • Golf
  • Tennis
  • Ray Ratto

 

TICKETS

  • Giants Tickets
  • A's Tickets
  • 49ers Tickets
  • Raiders Tickets
  • Warriors Tickets
  • Kings Tickets
  • Sharks Tickets
Curry Jersey
Giants Fitted Hat
49ers Hoodie

Mega Menu: Shop

  • Giants
  • A's Shop
  • 49ers
  • Raiders Shop
  • Warriors
  • Kings Shop
  • Sharks Shop

Mega Menu: Shop - Tickets

  • Giants Tickets
  • A's Tickets
  • 49ers Tickets
  • Raiders Tickets
  • Warriors Tickets
  • Kings Tickets
  • Sharks Tickets

Latest Videos

McLellan on Pavelski: 'He's got it going right now'
McLellan on Pavelski: 'He's got it going right now'
See more >

ONLINE SHOWS

  • Buster Knows Squat
  • Romo's Relief
  • Humm BB
  • Diamond Girls
  • Bullshootin'
  • Amy G.’s Exclusives
  • Learning with the Pros

TV SHOWS

  • All Videos
  • SportsNet Central
  • Yahoo SportsTalk Live
  • CSN Talent

INSIDERS

  • Ray Ratto - Senior Insider
  • Andrew Baggarly - Giants
  • Matt Maiocco - 49ers
  • Scott Bair - Raiders
  • Monte Poole - Warriors
  • Kevin Kurz - Sharks
  • Casey Pratt - Field of Teams
  • TV Schedule - Bay Area and California
  • Channel Locations - Bay Area
  • Channel Locations - California