Skip to main content

CSN Bay Area

HOME  >  NEWS  >  SPORTS
Ruling dismisses college athletes from forming union
Share This Post
Comments
Monday, August 17, 2015 - 2:15pm

CHICAGO -- The National Labor Relations Board on Monday blocked a historic bid by Northwestern University football players to form the nation's first college athletes' union, dealing a blow to a labor movement that could have transformed amateur sports.

In a unanimous decision, the board said the prospect of having both union and nonunion teams could lead to different standards at different schools - from the amount of money players receive to the amount of time they can practice - and create competitive imbalances on the field.

The ruling dismissed a stunning decision in March 2014 by a regional NLRB director in Chicago who said football players with scholarships are effectively school employees and entitled to organize. But Monday's decision did not directly address the question of whether the players are employees.

The face of the union drive, former Northwestern quarterback Kain Colter, expressed disappointment in the ruling. But he said the unionization drive pressured the NCAA to take athletes' grievances more seriously.

"Once we started this movement, within one year, things started changing," he said. "It turned out to be the right thing to do, and I don't regret it."

Northwestern welcomed the ruling, and its vice president for university relations, Alan K. Cubbage, praised pro-union players, saying the school applauded them "for bringing national attention to these important issues."

The labor dispute goes to the heart of American college sports, where universities and conferences reap billions of dollars, mostly through broadcast contracts, by relying on amateurs who are not paid. In other countries, college sports are small-time club affairs, while elite youth athletes often turn pro as teens.

The biggest factor in how it ruled, the board said, was the NLRB's jurisdiction, which extends only to private schools like Northwestern, the sole private institution in the Big Ten. The board repeatedly cited the need for standardization of rules and policies in sports and said that giving the green light to just one team to collectively bargain would disrupt that uniformity.

"Processing a petition for the scholarship players at this single institution under the circumstances presented here would not promote stability in labor relations," the ruling said.

NLRB rules do not offer the losing side a clear avenue to appeal Monday's decision. But Ramogi Huma, a former linebacker at UCLA and a union activist who worked closely with Colter, said he has not given up on bringing unions to college football.

"The door's not closed," he said.

The board seemed to leave open the possibly of taking up the unionization issue again if it involved other schools or if conditions change for Northwestern football.

Northwestern became the focal point of the labor fight in January 2014, when Colter announced plans to form the first U.S. labor union for college athletes. He appeared at a news conference for the College Athletes Players Association, flanked by leaders of the United Steelworkers union, which lent its organizing expertise and presumably helped bankroll the union drive.

Three months later, regional NLRB Director Peter Sung Ohr issued his stunning decision, saying Northwestern football players who receive scholarships fit the definition of employees under federal law and therefore should be able to unionize. A month later, football players cast secret ballots on whether to unionize. Those ballots were sealed during the appeal and will now be destroyed without being counted.

While NLRB decisions are sometimes split along party lines, the three Democrats and two Republicans on the board all agreed.

Under U.S. law, an employee is regarded as someone who, among other things, receives compensation for a service and is under the direct control of managers. In Northwestern's case, Ohr concluded that coaches are equivalent to business managers and scholarships are a form of pay.

The board's decision was welcome news for the NCAA. It has been under increasing scrutiny over its amateurism rules and has been fighting lawsuits from former athletes over everything from head injuries to revenue earned from the use of their likenesses in video games.

In a statement, the Indianapolis-based NCAA portrayed the board's ruling as recognition that it is trying to improve the lot of athletes.

"This ruling allows us to continue to make progress for the college athlete without risking the instability to college sports that the NLRB recognized might occur under the labor petition," it said.

The NCAA recently cleared the way for the five biggest conferences, including the Big Ten, to add player stipends to help athletes defray some of their expenses. Southeastern Conference schools, for example, will give some athletes $3,000 to $5,500 each on top of a scholarship that pays for tuition, room, board and books.

Northwestern, the Big Ten and the NCAA all argued against the unionization effort, saying that lumping college athletes into the same category as factory workers would change amateur athletics for the worse. At one point, Northwestern administrators sent a document to players outlining potential pitfalls, noting that player strikes could lead to the spectacle of replacement players.

The specific goals of the players association, or CAPA, included guaranteeing coverage of sports-related medical expenses for current and former players and reducing head injuries.

NBCBayArea.com

There is no data to display.

Video

Tomsula not worried about schedule quirk: 'Give us the parameters'
Morning Minute: Giants come up short; A's explode in Chicago
Bochy: 'Tough loss, but loved way they kept fighting' vs Reds
Kruk & Kuip: Giants suffer 'gut-wrench' loss to Reds

Giants

NL West Watch: Dodgers drop 16-inning marathon to Rockies
Rewind: Giants loss 'entertaining,' but heartbreaking
Instant Replay: Giants rally in ninth, fall to Reds in 10
Wild Card Watch: Cubs down Pirates, split doubleheader
Read More

Athletics

Zito returns to majors as A's shuffle roster
Rewind: By-the-numbers look at A's rout of White Sox
Instant Replay: A's jump on Samardzija, pound out 17 runs
A's notes: Chavez out for rest of season with rib fracture
Read More

Sharks

Sharks outlook: Braun a key cog as new contract kicks in
Sharks outlook: Brown may have trouble cracking lineup
Sharks outlook: Offensively dynamic, Burns' D must improve
Sharks sign second-round pick D Jeremy Roy
Read More

49ers

Tomsula takes 49ers' schedule challenge in stride
Hayne's 'learning moment' comes in 49ers' opener
49ers' O-line off to impressive start, 'make it easy' for Hyde
49ers RB Bush scheduled for MRI on left calf
Read More

Raiders

Reports: Jones fined for slamming Cooper's head, will appeal
Del Rio: Raiders will give Aldon Smith 'good structure and support'
Del Rio: Raiders QB Carr in 'good shape' to play vs Ravens
Grubman: San Diego, St. Louis won’t make stadium pitches
Read More

Warriors

Curry on Nash: 'Finally we get a decent coach around here'
Warriors release virtual tour of proposed new Mission Bay arena
Steve Nash finalizing deal to join Warriors staff
Warriors outlook: Barbosa good fit on floor, in locker room
Read More

NCAA

Ray Ratto's Top 25: Harbaugh's play card day-to-day
Hogan bounces back, leads Stanford past Central Florida
San Jose State routed by Air Force, falls to 1-1
Goff throws three TDs as Cal stomps San Diego State
Read More
  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • MLB Standings
  • Amy G
  • Insider Alex Pavlovic
  • Buy Giants Gear
  • Buy Giants Tickets

Latest News

NL West Watch: Dodgers drop 16-inning marathon to Rockies
(1)
Associated Press

GIANTS VIDEO

Bochy: 'Tough loss, but loved way they kept fighting' vs Reds
Bochy: 'Tough loss, but loved way they kept fighting' vs Reds
See more >

GIANTS INSIDER

  • Rewind: Giants loss 'entertaining,' but heartbreaking
  • Instant Replay: Giants rally in ninth, fall to Reds in 10
  • Giants notes: Crawford could return Wednesday
  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • MLB Standings
  • Insider Joe Stiglich
  • Buy Athletics Gear
  • Buy Athletics Tickets

Latest News

Zito returns to majors as A's shuffle roster
CSN Bay Area staff

A's VIDEO

Glen & Ray: Semien maturing both offensively and defensively
Glen & Ray: Semien maturing both offensively and defensively
See more >

A's INSIDER

  • Rewind: By-the-numbers look at A's rout of White Sox
  • Instant Replay: A's jump on Samardzija, pound out 17 runs
  • A's notes: Chavez out for rest of season with rib fracture
  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • NHL Standings
  • Insider Kevin Kurz
  • Buy Sharks Gear
  • Buy Sharks Tickets

Latest News

Sharks outlook: Braun a key cog as new contract kicks in
(2)
Kevin Kurz

SHARKS VIDEO

Kurz: With Jones in fold, Sharks still need help in several spots
Kurz: With Jones in fold, Sharks still need help in several spots
See more >

SHARKS INSIDER

There is no data to display.

  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • NBA Standings
  • Insider Monte Poole
  • Buy Warriors Gear
  • Buy Warriors Tickets

Latest News

Curry on Nash: 'Finally we get a decent coach around here'
(1)
CSN Bay Area staff

WARRIORS VIDEO

Warriors Mission Bay arena rendering
Warriors Mission Bay arena rendering
See more >

WARRIORS INSIDER

  • Warriors release virtual tour of proposed new Mission Bay arena
  • Steve Nash finalizing deal to join Warriors staff
  • Warriors outlook: Barbosa good fit on floor, in locker room
  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • NBA Standings
  • Buy Kings Gear
  • Buy Kings Tickets

Latest News

Report: Kings will bring back big man Eric Moreland
(1)
ProBasketballTalk

Kings Video

Sim Bhullar reveals he's 25-30 pounds lighter entering Summer League
Sim Bhullar reveals he's 25-30 pounds lighter entering Summer League
See more >

More Stories

Report: Kings among teams interested in C Hollins
(1)
Report: Kings sign former NCAA star Marshall Henderson
(2)
See more >
  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • NFL Standings
  • Insider Matt Maiocco
  • Buy 49ers Gear
  • Buy 49ers Tickets

Latest News

Tomsula takes 49ers' schedule challenge in stride
(18)
Matt Maiocco

49ers VIDEO

Tomsula not worried about schedule quirk: 'Give us the parameters'
Tomsula not worried about schedule quirk: 'Give us the parameters'
See more >

49ers INSIDER

  • Tomsula takes 49ers' schedule challenge in stride
  • Hayne's 'learning moment' comes in 49ers' opener
  • 49ers' O-line off to impressive start, 'make it easy' for Hyde
  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • NFL Standings
  • Insider Scott Bair
  • Buy Raiders Gear
  • Buy Raiders Tickets

Latest News

Reports: Jones fined for slamming Cooper's head, will appeal
(12)
Scott Bair

RAIDERS VIDEO

Ellis informs on ankle injury, status for Sunday vs Ravens
Ellis informs on ankle injury, status for Sunday vs Ravens
See more >

RAIDERS INSIDER

There is no data to display.

  • Scoreboard
  • Stats
  • Schedule
  • Roster
  • MLS Standings
  • MLS Player Leaders
  • Buy Quakes Gear
  • Buy Quakes Tickets

Top Story

Martins salvages 1-1 draw for Sounders at Quakes
Associated Press

Quakes Video

But Seriously: How do women's sports improve audience?
But Seriously: How do women's sports improve audience?
See more >

Quakes Shop

JOE STIGLICH

Rewind: By-the-numbers look at A's rout of White Sox
See more >

ALEX PAVLOVIC

Rewind: Giants loss 'entertaining,' but heartbreaking
(9)
See more >

MATT MAIOCCO

Tomsula takes 49ers' schedule challenge in stride
(18)
See more >

SCOTT BAIR

Reports: Jones fined for slamming Cooper's head, will appeal
(12)
See more >

MONTE POOLE

Warriors release virtual tour of proposed new Mission Bay arena
See more >

KEVIN KURZ

Sharks outlook: Braun a key cog as new contract kicks in
(2)
See more >

RAY RATTO

Nash's second order of business: redesign Warriors logo

ENTER TO WIN SHARKS TICKETS!

tix

Enter here for a chance to win a pair of tickets to the Predators vs Sharks game on 10/28!

AFF - A'S

Authentic Fan Friday - A's

Come to Authentic Fan Friday at the A's! 

Sit in the Value Deck and score free giveaways - get more info here!

 

ENTER TO WIN A TRIP TO UNIVERSAL ORLANDO!

nbc

Click here and enter to win a trip to Universal Orlando, presented by Bookit.com!

NCAA

  • Stanford Football
  • Stanford Basketball
  • Stanford Women's Basketball
  • Cal Football
  • Cal Basketball
  • Cal Women's Basketball
  • SJSU Football
  • SJSU Basketball
  • USF Basketball
  • USF Women's Basketball
  • Saint Mary's Basketball
  • Santa Clara Basketball
  • Fresno State Football

MORE

  • Biz Ball
  • SaberCats
  • Fight Sports
  • Motor Sports
  • GolfChannel.com
  • Tennis
  • Ray Ratto

 

TICKETS

  • Giants Tickets
  • A's Tickets
  • 49ers Tickets
  • Raiders Tickets
  • Warriors Tickets
  • Kings Tickets
  • Sharks Tickets
Curry Jersey
Giants Fitted Hat
49ers Hoodie

Mega Menu: Shop

  • Giants
  • A's Shop
  • 49ers
  • Raiders Shop
  • Warriors
  • Kings Shop
  • Sharks Shop

Mega Menu: Shop - Tickets

  • Giants Tickets
  • A's Tickets
  • 49ers Tickets
  • Raiders Tickets
  • Warriors Tickets
  • Kings Tickets
  • Sharks Tickets

Latest Videos

Tomsula not worried about schedule quirk: 'Give us the parameters'
Tomsula not worried about schedule quirk: 'Give us the parameters'
See more >

ORIGINAL PROGRAMMING

  • G-Mag
  • All A's
  • Carpool Confessions
  • Amy G’s Exclusives
  • Eireann Dolan's Call to the 'Pen
  • When Giants Fan Met Dodgers Fan

TV SHOWS

  • All Videos
  • SportsNet Central
  • SportsTalk Live
  • But Seriously

INSIDERS

  • Ray Ratto - Senior Insider
  • Matt Maiocco - 49ers
  • Scott Bair - Raiders
  • Monte Poole - Warriors
  • Kevin Kurz - Sharks
  • Joe Stiglich - A's
  • Alex Pavlovic - Giants
  • TV Schedule - Bay Area and California
  • Channel Locations - Bay Area
  • Channel Locations - California